This is the first phase of our approach to working with clients for whom shame and self-criticism cause serious problems. Before trying to directly address shame or the inner critic, therapist and client spend a few sessions building a shared understanding: what shame and self-criticism do in the client’s life, where they came from, and what experiences of warmth the client can draw on. That understanding, and the relationship built while forging it, becomes the foundation for the work that follows.
The preparation phase grew out of the case conceptualization framework we published here in 2020, and it replaces it. It is rooted in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and also draws on compassion-focused therapy, emotion-focused therapy, radically open dialectical behavior therapy and affective science, so therapists who work from other models can use it too.
Download the guide (PDF, 53 pages)
Building a Foundation for Working with Shame and Self-Criticism: The Preparation Phase of ACT with Compassion, by Jason Luoma, Jenna LeJeune and M. Kati Lear. Version 1.0, November 2026.
The four steps
- Introducing shame and self-criticism as a possible focus for therapy. Many clients don’t arrive asking for help with shame. The therapist names what they’ve noticed in the client’s own terms (a harsh inner critic, a sense of not being good enough, perfectionism) and suggests a few questionnaires to complete before the next session.
- Exploring how shame and self-criticism function in the client’s life. Reviewing the questionnaires together, therapist and client look at when shame and self-criticism show up, what they say, and what they cost. Talking about them openly, with someone who listens without judgment, begins to loosen their hold.
- Developing a compassionate perspective by exploring contributing events. Using a history handout, the therapist offers tentative guesses about how past criticism, rejection or neglect could have taught the client to see themselves as flawed, and checks whether each one fits. The aim is a story that makes sense of the client’s shame without blaming them for it.
- Identifying key social safeness resources. Therapist and client look for relationships and moments of warmth, belonging or kindness, however brief, that later work can draw on.
Two threads run through all four steps: the therapist’s empathy and validation, including the nonverbal signals that tell a shame-prone client they are safe, and re-conceptualization, the shift from “something is wrong with me” to “I have a relationship with myself, and it can change.” The phase usually takes three to five sessions.
Handouts and measures for each step
Step 1
- The three questionnaires we give: the Internalized Shame Scale (our last-week version), the FSCRS and the SCS-SF, with free scoring templates
Step 2: building awareness
- Shame psychoeducation handout, for clients who don’t yet recognize shame in their lives (about this handout)
- Learning about Shame worksheet, for noticing shame as it happens (about this worksheet)
- Shame, Belonging, and Connection, for clients who feel ashamed of feeling shame: why shame evolved and how it gets stuck
- Writing about self-criticism, comparing how clients speak to themselves with how they would speak to a friend
- Building awareness of self-criticism, a form for tracking what self-criticism actually leads to
Steps 3 and 4: the history handouts
- Understanding Your History Related to Shame and Self-Criticism, given at the end of Step 2 and discussed in Step 3 (how to introduce and debrief it)
- Your Experience of Warm and Supportive Relationships, given at the end of Step 3 and discussed in Step 4 (about this handout)
Related
- Criticism vs. Responsivity handout, for clients who can’t see where their self-criticism came from because no one was openly critical (read the post)
To hear about new tools and resources as we add them, sign up for our free newsletter.